Pinch vs GoCardless vs Stripe in Xero: Which Payment Option Actually Combines Both?

Pinch is the only major Xero-connected payment platform that processes both BECS direct debit and card payments through a single integration. GoCardless handles direct debit collection. Stripe handles card payments. Businesses that want to offer customers both usually connect both, which means two logins, two fee structures, and two reconciliation processes running side by side in Xero.

Pinch does what GoCardless and Stripe do in Xero, combined.

This article breaks down what each platform actually does, where they overlap, and what changes when a business runs one payment platform instead of two.

What GoCardless Does in Xero

GoCardless is a direct debit collection platform. In Xero, it lets a business pull recurring or one-off payments straight from a customer's bank account using BECS.

GoCardless does not process credit or debit card payments. A business using GoCardless for direct debit still needs a separate provider, commonly Stripe, if it wants to accept cards on the same invoices.

What GoCardless Doesn't Do in Xero

• No card payment acceptance
• No built-in option to offer customers a choice between a bank account and a card on the same invoice
• Requires a second payment provider for full payment method coverage

What Stripe Does in Xero

Stripe is a card payment gateway. In Xero, it lets a business accept credit and debit card payments on invoices, with funds typically settling quickly due to how card schemes process transactions.

Stripe's core Xero integration is built around cards. Bank-to-bank direct debit is not part of the standard Stripe-Xero connection most small businesses use.

What Stripe Doesn't Do in Xero

• No native BECS direct debit collection in the standard integration
• Customers without a card, or who prefer not to use one, aren't covered
• A business wanting bank account debits still needs a second provider, commonly GoCardless

What Pinch Does in Xero

Pinch connects to Xero once and processes both BECS direct debit and card payments from the same invoice. The customer chooses how they want to pay. Pinch handles the collection, and Xero reflects the result automatically.

Direct Debit Through Pinch

Pinch processes direct debit through BECS, the system used for bank-to-bank payments in Australia. Because BECS doesn't confirm fund availability instantly, Pinch marks the invoice as paid once the debit is submitted, then reverses it if the bank later returns a dishonour. Direct debit payments currently settle to the merchant on a T+2 basis on average.

Card Payments Through Pinch

Card payments through Pinch are processed instantly. The card scheme confirms funds availability in real time, so the invoice updates in Xero immediately, and funds are settled the next business day.

Reconciliation in Xero: One Process, Not Two

Every Pinch payment, whether by direct debit or card, reconciles back into Xero automatically. There's one settlement record to check, not one from a direct debit provider and a separate one from a card provider.

Pinch vs GoCardless vs Stripe

Why Running Two Payment Apps Costs More Than Money

Two providers mean two logins, two support queues, and two sets of fees to track. It also means reconciling two settlement reports against the same set of Xero invoices, which adds admin time every week rather than saving it.

A single platform for both payment methods removes that duplication. One connection to manage, one settlement process to check, and one place to see which invoices are paid, pending, or overdue.

Which Invoicing Businesses Benefit From One Combined Payment Platform?

Any business that invoices customers and lets them choose how to pay benefits from a combined platform. This applies to businesses running invoice-based billing, where some customers pay by card and others prefer direct debit from their bank account. Common examples include:

• SaaS businesses billing customers on recurring plans
• Agencies invoicing clients with varied payment preferences
• Small businesses that want to reduce the time spent on admin and reconciliation

Pinch is built around invoice-based workflows in Xero. Every invoice can offer both direct debit and card payment on the same customer portal, so the business doesn't need to run separate tools for each payment type.

See how other businesses use Pinch

FAQs